Author: john
Date posted: 10/8/2001 8:41:53 PM
john's Comments:

been waiting for this one for a long time quiller. .. . thanks for rounding it out. The insight into obi-wan here is fantastic, especially the resignation at the end to defeat and waiting. and service. i thought it was well done, and i enjoyed it more than i did its predecessors. thanks quiller.

Author: Jeff 42  (signed)
Date posted: 10/10/2001 7:31:12 PM
Jeff 42's Comments:

Another outstanding story. The portrayal of Obi-Wan was very good. Thank you, Quiller, for sharing your vision with us. These three stories make up one of the most amazing works of fan fiction I've seen.

Author: C4GO
Date posted: 10/10/2001 9:47:18 PM
C4GO's Comments:

Very nice! It almost made me cry!

Author: James T. Skywalker
Date posted: 10/13/2001 9:29:18 AM
James T. Skywalker's Comments:

I was very pleased to see the conclusion to your trilogy. This was a very well thought out story, and I applaud you. Very good job, and congratulations to you.

Author: BW Harbinger  (signed)
Date posted: 10/13/2001 11:46:05 PM
BW Harbinger's Comments:

This is quite simply the best piece of fan fiction I've ever read.

Surveying this masterpiece on the same level of The Phantom Menace is ridiculous... the quality behind this work far surpasses any Pre-OT media I've seen yet.

Quiller - you write with great fluidity and grace. You know how to properly slip in the tough words with precision and without sounding pretentious. These talents and your ability to tell a Star Wars tale involving the heart's and soul's of the characters (instead of spewing encyclopedia material and political, science-fiction nonsense) really set you apart from a lot of fanfic and about all EU writers.

This work actually felt "Star Warsish." And that's the first time I've ever experienced that. This trilogy really clicked with the original Star Wars movies.

You are really a master of words... I commend you, and keep it up! =)

Author: Mcily Nochi
Date posted: 12/1/2001 9:59:15 PM
Mcily Nochi's Comments:

Wow. Wow. Wow. T

Author: Mcily Nochi
Date posted: 12/1/2001 9:59:17 PM
Mcily Nochi's Comments:

Wow. Wow. Wow. T

Author: Mcily Nochi
Date posted: 12/1/2001 10:01:48 PM
Mcily Nochi's Comments:

Okay, I don't know what just happened, but this comment decided to post before I was done, so I'll just continue it now.

This story realy completed your trilogy, and that saying a lot. Many people who try to write a trilogy that's as excellent as this are unable to really end it. And you managed that. Not only that, you mananged to end with a whisper, not a bang. Great job, Quiller, and I hope to see more of your work soon.

Mcily

Author: 2nd hand liver
Date posted: 12/6/2001 9:59:22 AM
2nd hand liver's Comments:

Well written, very vivid, great use of imagery. Nice work there.

Author: J.
Date posted: 12/6/2001 4:53:24 PM
J.'s Comments:

Encore! Encore!

Author: Azlon Tir
Date posted: 12/8/2001 2:19:13 PM
Azlon Tir's Comments:

Once again I loved every word of your story, but there is one thing left to be desired. I want to see the fight that claimed Anakin's humanity. I want to see how Obi Wan nearly killed his former aprentice, only to rescue him from the fires of the lava pool he forecd Anakin into, The final transition into Darth Vader. Please write that story. I beg you.

Author: CenterSpire
Date posted: 1/10/2002 6:24:05 PM
CenterSpire's Comments:

This trilogy is simply the best fan fiction (of any kind) that I have ever read. Fantastic execution. Wonderful emotions and struggles. I'll try not to be disapointed when this doesn't show up in canon.

Author: Mizhnari Windu
Date posted: 3/28/2002 12:16:42 PM
Mizhnari Windu's Comments:

I don't know who you are or what kind of person you are but your genious and talent aren't the only elements that make this work/trilogy an EPIC. As an actor and SW fan I can appreciate what you've done here on many levels. Not only has a life-long memory been created but also a vision of true beauty. To do that requires more than someone giving their time and effort but it demands something few people have the courage or ability to do. It requires you to give a piece of your soul. Being blessed with the gift to do so and do it so pleasingly is a great honor. All else has already been said so I'll just add, thanks again.


P.S. If you don't continue to write it would be a crime.

Author: Jedi_Kara  (signed)
Date posted: 6/14/2002 6:25:33 PM
Jedi_Kara's Comments:

This is one of the coolest fanfics I have read so far. It shows Obi-Wan (in my opinion anyway) very well. I think he would have been feeling very guilty over Anakin's betrayal. Very good job.

Author: vader-incarnate  (signed)
Date posted: 8/2/2002 3:48:36 AM
vader-incarnate's Comments:

Oh, jeez, Obi never gets anything, does he? He loses everything for the Force. EVERYTHING. It's incredible the way you portray him in this story. Oh, gee, I think I'm going to go change my screenname now....

--Vader-Incarnate

Author: Reihla
Date posted: 8/8/2002 2:40:30 PM
Reihla's Comments:

Beautifully written trilogy! You have an awesome gift for comfortable, incharacter dialogue. I've often imagined things happened just this way, but it was great not to tell myself the story for a change!

Author: myn donos
Date posted: 8/11/2002 8:14:12 AM
myn donos's Comments:

Ah, Obi wan, the unsung tragic hero. Very well done; thank you for the added insight into one of my favorite characters.

Author: Lady Padme  (signed)
Date posted: 8/13/2002 8:00:46 PM
Lady Padme's Comments:

I really enjoyed all three stories in your trilogy...I had to keep telling myself that the last movie hadn't come out yet, since these scenarios were so believable and melded so smoothly with the Star Wars mythology. Wonderful!

Author: Cristy
Date posted: 8/20/2002 3:51:24 PM
Cristy's Comments:

It was written pretty good but I really did not like the way the writer made Obi-wan in love with Amidala that is very messed up.

Author: Quiller  (signed)
Date posted: 8/24/2002 11:06:44 AM
Quiller's Comments:

Cristy, since I couldn't reach you via email, I thought I'd reply here. You're absolutely right -- in light of AOTC, it is obvious that there is no love between Obi-Wan and Amidala. When I wrote the story, there was some speculation that perhaps there would be, and that that very thing might be one of the reasons Anakin turned. I liked that idea because it mirrored the triangle that existed between Han, Leia and Luke.

I always knew this trilogy would become AU someday. AOTC just made it happen faster.

Author: JadeSolo
Date posted: 10/6/2002 11:45:32 AM
JadeSolo's Comments:

Stunning, especially the very end when Obi-Wan lets it all go.

I'm not a fan of the whole prequel love triangle mess, but I thought it worked incredibly well here. It gave Anakin yet another reason to turn to the Dark Side and made Obi-Wan suffer even more.

I love to read your stories. Please write more.

Author: Barissa
Date posted: 10/11/2002 6:56:40 PM
Barissa's Comments:

Wow. All. I. Can. Say. Is. Wow. That insight to Obi Wan, is nuts, I have such a respect for him now. I really liked him before, but now, geesh, I am utterly stoaked at how he acted, and how fully Anakin accepted the darkness. Wow, excelent job Quiller, Absolutely excelent.

Author: Jedi Dax Jentor
Date posted: 1/28/2003 3:30:12 PM
Jedi Dax Jentor's Comments:

Absolutely the most amazing FanFic I have ever read. I am utterly impressed with your grasp of the characters and your ability to create a story that fits so well into the Saga. Please write a fourth and fifth episode to go along with these three.

Note to readers: READ THIS TRILOGY. It is amazing. Again, I repeat, I have never read a better FanFic.

Author: Barriss
Date posted: 3/19/2003 2:33:17 PM
Barriss's Comments:

IMPRESSIVE. THIS WAS THE LAST ONE OF THE TRILOGY THAT I HAD YET TO READ. SO NOW IT IS AMIDALA AND BAIL.......ALRIGHTY THEN. VERY NICE.

Author: Valiowk  (signed)
Date posted: 4/8/2003 10:13:21 AM
Valiowk's Comments:

This is such an amazing story. It has brought out so many emotions; it has dealt so comprehensively with so many little details, e.g. how Obi-Wan came to be called "Ben", his hidden feelings for Amidala, his friendship with Bail Organa.

The part where Bail points out that the Daksheen did not die for Obi-Wan, rather they died for freedom is fantastic. It has enclosed such truth and wisdom within.

Thank you for a beautiful tale.

Author: jedilittlebee
Date posted: 4/15/2003 4:11:50 PM
jedilittlebee's Comments:

I loved the way Obi-Wan faced his demons and came out whole. I especially liked the way you ended it with the scene from ANH. I read that you had another story on your home page following this one called "Shadow and Light", but couldn't find it-an error notice came up and said to tell the webmaster. Is there another one? Could you let me know if there is and you could post it here? Thanks, Debbie

Author: erica
Date posted: 2/7/2004 6:19:19 AM
erica's Comments:

That was the best piece of writing i've encountered ever (and not just from the SW genre). You deserve to have publishers banging down your door. The development of Obi-wan is amazing in the trilogy, but the depth in this final piece is so realistic that I almost cried at several points (a feat never before accomplished). The anguish is palpable and themes brought up with the characters of Calder and family are inspiring. I can't bring the right words to mind to encompass how this piece affected me, it was sheer brilliance. You have a gift...

Author: MutantJediBouer  (signed)
Date posted: 4/8/2004 8:42:13 PM
MutantJediBouer's Comments:

I agree with some of the others, Obi-Wan and most of the characters in more than one paragraph were very well developed. Again, I love your work, it's truly amazing. This must be the third time I've read this trilogy now and it still proves to be fascinating. Come what may, come what may... Wonder where I've heard that before... ;-Þ Anyway, it's absolutely Force-inspired, lovely, I can't wait to see your next story. The writing is great, but it's the tiny bits that make it a work of art.
MutantJediBauer
aka. Zax-Ryn Kenobi

Author: Shaft_Windu
Date posted: 5/23/2004 7:56:40 PM
Shaft_Windu's Comments:

Wow, I agree with everyone's comments before me and just to reiterate, this is THE best fan SW story I've ever read. It is definitely on par with my favorite SW writer Timothy Zahn, the way you integrated the whole story, developing Obi-wan, it was all just fantastic. A real treat to read and hopefully you will have many more in the future.

Author: cdmcc  (signed)
Date posted: 5/11/2005 2:08:24 PM
cdmcc's Comments:

Must say I feel Quiller is probably the best fanfic writer I've read. I like the way that Obi-Wan is brought to life. A bi of the human touch. Great!

Author: Kalabus
Date posted: 10/30/2005 11:56:04 AM
Kalabus's Comments:

Great style. Read pt2 and thought you captured Anakin well, but this was a great insight into Obi-Wan. Absolutely great ending with the epilogue. Makes me want to break out all the movies and have a marathon. :)